Retail Menu

LITTLE PIE COMPANY

424 West 43rd Street (212) 736-4780
www.littlepiecompany.com

All of our pies are handmade from scratch using only the finest ingredients

Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie

Our signature pie is made with fresh Granny Smith apples!

Old-Fashioned Apple Pie

Traditionally spiced Golden Delicious apples in a domed crust
10 inch: $30.00 8 inch: $23.00 5 inch: $8.00 10 inch: $30.00 8 inch: $23.00 5 inch: $8.00

Pear Apple Crumb Pie (seasonal)

Anjou Pears & Granny Smith Apples with a cinnamon crumb topping

Florida Key Lime Pie

Smooth and piquant filling with a graham cracker crust
10 inch: $30.00 8 inch: $23.00 5 inch: $8.00 10 inch: $30.00 8 inch: $23.00 5 inch: $8.00

Threeberry Pie

Strawberries, blueberries and raspberries combined!

Southern Pecan Pie

Rich and tender pastry compliments our traditional filling
10 inch: $30.00 8 inch: $23.00 5 inch: $8.00 10 inch: $30.00 5 inch: $8.00

Mississippi Mud Pie

Our triple chocolate treat featured on the Food Network!

Banana Coconut Cream Pie

Fresh Bananas and coconut cream
10 inch: $30.00 8 inch: $23.00 5 inch: $8.00 10 inch: $30.00 8 inch: $23.00 5 inch: $8.00

Montmorency Cherry Pie

Monmorency Cherries, lattice crust

Sugarless Apple Pie

*24 hour advance payment required, no artificial sweeteners
10 inch: $30.00 8 inch: $23.00 5 inch: $8.00 10 inch: $30.00

Pies and cakes by the slice $4.00
A la Mode $1.50
Ice Cream by the scoop $2.50

Homemade Cakes

Applesauce Carrot Cake

Light yet superbly rich and moist

Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake

Belgian chocolate & Dutch cocoa in our family recipe!
Large: $35.00 Medium: $23.00 Small: $12.00 Large: $35.00 Medium: $23.00 Small: $12.00

Red Velvet Cake

A mild chocolate cake with a little buttermilk and cream cheese icing

Creamy New York Cheese Cake

Creamy, yet slightly dense
Large: $35.00 Medium: $23.00 Small: $12.00 Large: $32.00 Small: $5.00

Decadent Cupcakes

Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet and Applesauce Carrot $3.00
Cookies & Cream, Peanut Butter Chocolate, Coconut
*Please ask about our special occasion cakes and decoration.

Other Desserts

Oven-Fresh Muffins

$3.00

Bread Loaves:

$18.00
Blueberry, Corn, Banana Nut, Cinnamon, Raisin Bran, Orange, Apple Cinnamon Banana Nut, Lemon Pound
By the Slice
$3.00

Sour Cream Coffee Cake

$4.00

Brownies

Fresh Apple Turnovers

$3.00 Plain & Walnut Brownie $3.00

Piping-Hot Chicken Pot Pie

$8.00

Home-Baked Cookies

Bread Pudding

$5.00

Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Coconut

$1.50


*Store Hours*
Monday-Friday 8am-8pm
Saturday 10am-8pm.; Sunday 10am-6pm
All Purchases are Final. No exchanges or refunds.
Little Pie Company bakes with 0 grams trans fats and contain no preservatives or artificial ingredients
Therefore must be stored in the refrigerator if kept overnight.