Retail Menu


424 West 43rd Street (212) 736-4780

All of our pies are handmade from scratch using only the finest ingredients

Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie

Our signature pie is made with fresh Granny Smith apples!

Old-Fashioned Apple Pie

Traditionally spiced Golden Delicious apples in a domed crust
10 inch: $30.00 8 inch: $23.00 5 inch: $8.00 10 inch: $30.00 8 inch: $23.00 5 inch: $8.00

Mississippi Mud Pie

Our triple chocolate treat featured on the Food Network!

Florida Key Lime Pie

Smooth and piquant filling with a graham cracker crust
10 inch: $30.00 8 inch: $23.00 5 inch: $8.00 10 inch: $30.00 8 inch: $23.00 5 inch: $8.00

Threeberry Pie

Strawberries, blueberries and raspberries combined!

Southern Pecan Pie

Rich and tender pastry compliments our traditional filling
10 inch: $30.00 8 inch: $23.00 5 inch: $8.00 10 inch: $30.00 5 inch: $8.00

Sweet Potato Pie (Seasonal)

When in season, we use fresh Kentucky Sweet Potatoes

Banana Coconut Cream Pie

Fresh Bananas and coconut cream
10 inch: $25.00 8 inch: $18.00 5 inch: $8.00 10 inch: $30.00 8 inch: $23.00 5 inch: $8.00

Pumpkin Pie (Seasonal)

Delicately spiced, traditionally American

Sugarless Apple Pie

*24 hour advance payment required, no artificial sweeteners
10 inch: $25.00 8 inch: $18.00 5 inch: $8.00 10 inch: $30.00

Pies and cakes by the slice $4.00
A la Mode $1.50
Ice Cream by the scoop $2.50

Homemade Cakes

Applesauce Carrot Cake

Light yet superbly rich and moist

Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake

Belgian chocolate & Dutch cocoa in our family recipe!
Large: $35.00 Medium: $23.00 Small: $12.00 Large: $35.00 Medium: $23.00 Small: $12.00

Red Velvet Cake

A mild chocolate cake with a little buttermilk and
cream cheese icing

Creamy New York Cheese Cake

Creamy, yet slightly dense
Large: $35.00 Medium: $23.00 Small: $12.00 Large: $32.00 Small: $5.00

Decadent Cupcakes

Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, Applesauce Carrot
Cookies & Cream, Chocolate Mocha Cream
*Please ask about our special occasion cakes and decoration.

Other Desserts

Oven-Fresh Muffins


Bread Loaves:

Blueberry, Corn, Banana Nut, Cinnamon, Raisin Bran, Orange, Apple Cinnamon Banana Nut, Lemon Pound
By the Slice

Sour Cream Coffee Cake



Fresh Apple Turnovers

$3.00 Plain & Walnut Brownie $3.00

Piping-Hot Chicken Pot Pie


Home-Baked Cookies

Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Snickerdoodle $1.50

*Store Hours*
Monday-Friday 8am-8pm
Saturday 10am-8pm.; Sunday 10am-6pm
All Purchases are Final. No exchanges or refunds.
Little Pie Company bakes with 0 grams trans fats and contain no preservatives or artificial ingredients
Therefore must be stored in the refrigerator if kept overnight.