The Perfect Ingredient to Build Your Business

The Little Pie Company was built with pride and founded on simple honesty. How could we offer you anything less than the best? We prefer something special and so should your customers.

There are never any secret fillers or curious ingredients in our handmade-as-always, purely fresh pies.

In 1985, Arnold Wilkerson took the idea of a home-style American kitchen to create a ‘theater of baking’ that has matured over the years into a rare pearl in the theater district. Naturally, we take great pleasure in offering such nurtured, careful luxury to our savvy clientele.

Imagine bringing a New York City classic to your restaurant with Little Pie Company! The delight is priceless as customers set their sights on creamy New York Cheesecake after a juicy rib-eye at a revered steakhouse. Perhaps they’d prefer to pick up our absolutely necessary Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie at their favorite gourmet grocery store or kick back with a cup of rich, steaming cappuccino and a wedge of our succulent Southern Pecan Pie at a hot neighborhood coffee spot.

Allow us to bring our reputation and time-saving reliability to your table and check desserts on your to-do list as ‘done!’

We use Golden Delicious apples for their uncompromising sweetness when stuffing our seasonally-scented Old-Fashioned Apple Pie, the highest quality, luscious Belgian chocolate floods our Mississippi Mud pie with brownie streusel and our hand-crimped golden crusts have aroused the interest of Food Network when Chef Flay stopped in for a fresh pie baking lesson on his hit show Throwdown with Bobby Flay.  We incorporate fine touches such as these into our desserts with a loving hand—they are never mass-produced on an unfeeling assembly line.

After a 20 year run, we’ve still got the best reviews in the theater district. The New York Times asserts ours is “the perfect pie” while Oprah compares our Florida Key Lime Pie to a “slice of summer.” Sarah Jessica Parker considers our Pumpkin Pie as “non-negotiable” for Thanksgiving, Eater numbers us among “9 Excellent Pie Shops Around New York City,” Rachael Ray voted our Southern Pecan Pie the “best mail-order pie in America” and the Daily News raved that our Sour Cream Walnut Apple Pie is “knock-your-socks-off delicious.”

Offer your customers a sweet slice of the best—astonishing desserts they’ll think you made yourself. The Little Pie Company is sure to receive an eating ovation—all the time, every time!

For questions or to place an order by phone please call (877) 872-7437.
Our office is open Mon-Fri. 9am-5pm EST.


424 West 43 Street
(between 9th and 10th Avenues)
New York, NY 10036
(212) 736-4780