Menu
Order Now

I Voted!

I Voted!

Voting is Sweeter With Discounted Treats! The 2020 presidential election is almost two weeks away — and we feel so fortunate (and incredibly excited!)

35th Anniversary Celebration!

35th Anniversary Celebration!

Stop by Little Pie Company today to get a first look at our renovated space, savor your favorite pies and pastries, and win incredible prizes!

We’re getting a Fabulous Bakeover!

We’re getting a Fabulous Bakeover!

After 35 years, we’ve made the exciting decision to renovate our iconic Theater District bakery. Since 1985, our team has grown and expanded, which means its time to welcome a new generation to the LPC family — and there’s no better time like the present, right?

American As Apple Pie

American As Apple Pie

Our business has always been built on love, family, and loyalty. In the 30-plus years we’ve been around, we are constantly striving to raise the bar when it comes to crafting high-quality, fresh handmade pies and desserts.

NY Bourbon and Pie: A Perfect Gift for Dad!

NY Bourbon and Pie: A Perfect Gift for Dad!

Surprise Dad with our new Hudson Baby Bourbon Pecan Pie for Father’s Day. In honor of Father’s Day, Little Pie Company teamed up with Hudson Whiskey — the first-ever bourbon produced in New York State — to create the ultimate Father’s Day Gift. 

Little Pie Company celebrates the Oscars

Little Pie Company celebrates the Oscars

The red carpet is soon to be rolled out for the Oscars on February 9th this year! One thing we at Little Pie Company can easily predict: we’ll be giving away a free large dessert of choice to ten participants who have the highest scores in our annual Oscar contest!

POM: Chocolate Pecan Pie

POM: Chocolate Pecan Pie

The Chocolate Pecan Pie is back! At Little Pie Company, we feel that everything goes better with chocolate–and our favorite holiday Pecan Pie filled with crunchy pecans layered over a creamy center is draped with lots of rich Belgian chocolate to add a deep, chocolaty dimension to our Pie of the Month!

Let Us Ship Pies to You or A Loved One!

Let Us Ship Pies to You or A Loved One!

Thanksgiving is soon to be upon us–and the last day to place an order for your seasonal favorites is 11/18! Let us ship a Pumpkin Pie, Salted Caramel Pie, Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie, Old Fashioned Apple, or Pecan Pie to you for your table or as a gift to your loved ones.

Let's Connect

Close

Join Us!

Join our newsletter to receive new product updates, special discounts and exclusive offers.